Skip to main content

Concussion Management of New York

Sports Concussion Assessment: Evaluating Diagnostic Tools & Recovery Protocols

Mount Sinai Provider Network

When an athlete sustains a hit to the head, performing an immediate sports concussion assessment is critical to protecting long-term brain health. Because a concussion is a functional brain injury rather than a structural one, standard imaging like CT scans or MRIs cannot detect it. Instead, sports medicine specialists rely on validated cognitive, visual, and balance screening tools to track recovery and manage safe return-to-play decisions.

A landmark clinical review evaluating these diagnostic metrics—co-authored by Dr. Alex Gometz of Concussion Management of New York—was published in Cureus under the title “Review of Assessment Scales for Diagnosing and Monitoring Sports-related Concussion”.

Below is a breakdown of the core assessment scales used in modern sports neurology.

Core Tools Used in Sports Concussion Assessment

1. Standardized Assessment of Concussion (SAC)

The SAC is a 5-minute paper-and-pencil sideline screening evaluating four cognitive domains:

  • Orientation (date, time, location)
  • Immediate Memory (word recall trials)
  • Concentration (digits backward, reverse months)
  • Delayed Recall (delayed word retrieval)

Clinical Insight: The SAC demonstrates high sensitivity (80%–94%) for catching immediate deficits, but scores often normalize within 48 hours. A normal SAC score after two days does not mean physiological recovery is complete, so it should never serve as a standalone clearance tool.

2. Sport Concussion Assessment Tool (SCAT3 & Child SCAT3)

The SCAT3 (ages 13+) and Child SCAT3 (ages 5–12) combine several evaluations into a structured clinical battery:

  • Glasgow Coma Scale & Maddocks Score for acute triage
  • Symptom Evaluation Checklist to track severity over time
  • Cognitive Screening via the SAC framework
  • Balance Exams using the Modified Balance Error Scoring System (BESS)

3. Computerized Neurocognitive Testing (ImPACT)

Computerized tools like ImPACT measure fine-grained cognitive performance across key composite scores:

  • Verbal & Visual Memory
  • Visual-Motor Speed (VMS)
  • Reaction Time (RT)

Comparing post-injury scores against a healthy pre-season baseline helps clinicians detect subtle processing speed and reaction time deficits that standard physical exams miss.

4. Oculomotor Screening: King-Devick (K-D) Test

Concussions frequently impair saccadic eye movements. The King-Devick Test is a timed number-naming exercise. A drop in K-D performance compared to baseline serves as a rapid, objective indicator of visual tracking and brainstem disruption.

Why a Multimodal Approach Matters

No single test can independently diagnose or clear a concussion. Safe management requires a four-tier approach:

  1. Sideline Screening: SAC, K-D, or SCAT metrics for immediate triage.
  2. Computerized Testing: ImPACT to evaluate memory and reaction speed.
  3. Vestibular & Balance Checks: Visual tracking and postural stability exams.
  4. Graduated Return-to-Play: Step-by-step exertion monitoring before contact clearance.

Specialized Concussion Care in New York

At Concussion Management of New York, Dr. Alex Gometz and our clinical team utilize peer-reviewed research and state-of-the-art diagnostic technology to evaluate head injuries and guide athletes through structured recovery.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q: Can a standard MRI or CT scan diagnose a concussion?

A: No. Imaging rules out structural damage like bleeding or fractures, but functional tools like ImPACT and SAC are required to evaluate cellular-level brain disruption.

Q: When is an athlete ready to return to play?

A: Only after completing a medically supervised exertion protocol, remaining symptom-free at rest and during activity, and matching healthy baseline scores on cognitive and balance tests.

Reference & Publication Details

  • Title: Review of Assessment Scales for Diagnosing and Monitoring Sports-related Concussion
  • Journal: Cureus (2017)
  • Authors: Alexa M. Dessy, Frank J. Yuk, Akbar Y. Maniya, Alex Gometz, Jonathan J. Rasouli, Mark R. Lovell, Tanvir F. Choudhri
  • PubMed Entry: View Full Study on PubMed

Contact our office today to schedule an evaluation with a concussion specialist.

Disclaimer: This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Reading this post does not create a doctor-patient relationship with Concussion Management of New York. For personalized diagnosis and treatment of head injuries, please schedule a consultation with our clinical team or seek immediate emergency care if symptoms are severe.